Vacation Rental Specialists & Full Real Estate Services Since 1995.

$5,750 /Low Season Weekly Rate *** Special limited time Fall discount - 30% OFF!! ***
$6,900 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$10,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$800 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,100 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,600 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$3,200 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,800 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,995 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,800 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,400 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate SPECIAL March & April 2018 $5500.00
$5,280 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$3,250 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$3,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,800 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$3,995 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$6,195 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$6,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$7,000 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,900 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,600 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$1,600 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$4,500 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$2,400 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$6,850 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$3,995 /Low Season Weekly Rate
$6,800 /Low Season Weekly Rate
Traci Kirby-de Mena
Traci Kirby-de Mena
2017-10-21T17:17:16+0000
Great experience. Seamless transaction and check in. Great property with a nice pool and fishing pier. Morganna Anholt was very helpful in making this a perfect stay.
Bill Springer
Bill Springer
2017-10-18T18:17:12+0000
We love working with American Realty of Captiva. They are honest and respond right away. The properties they represent are listed realistically - no deception as we experienced in other parts of Florida. If there are problems, they solve them. WE MISS CAPTIVA and can't wait until we are there next year!!
Valerie Day Wilden
Valerie Day Wilden
2017-10-17T17:52:58+0000
Victoria Krause Schutte
Victoria Krause Schutte
2017-10-14T20:53:47+0000
Travis Furlow
Travis Furlow
2017-10-08T18:21:55+0000
Very responsive and easy to work with. We've stayed at ARC properties a couple of times and have always had a good experience with the entire booking process. We look at ARC properties first, before anywhere else. Highly recommended.
Tony Oust
Tony Oust
2017-10-07T15:46:37+0000
We have been staying at American Realty properties every year for over a dozen years. Every house was well appointed and very comfortable. Chuck and Elaine and staff go out of their way to make sure our stay is perfect! We have a treasure trove of family memories thanks to American Realty!
Terri Shepard Kanter
Terri Shepard Kanter
2017-10-05T22:11:18+0000
Have had nothing but fine assistance and cooperation from Elaine and Chuck. Plan to continue coming as long as able.Tom Hartman
Thomas E. Hartman
Thomas E. Hartman
2017-10-03T17:02:35+0000
Sondra Slattery
Sondra Slattery
2017-09-30T17:52:20+0000
American Realty of Captiva did a wonderful job for us in our quest for the perfect cottage to rent with our son and daughter in law and our little dog. They kept us up to date on things we needed to know to be prepared for the perfect week.
Alice Cramer Glass
Alice Cramer Glass
2017-09-24T16:20:27+0000
We have booked rental houses for several years with American Realty of Captiva. The owners and their staff are always friendly and professional making the reservation process seamless. They always respond immediately to our requests for help during our stays in the properties they manage. Five stars is an easy decision and you will receive 5-star service from American Realty.
Steve Beeland
Steve Beeland
2017-09-23T11:09:28+0000
We have been vacationing at Captiva for almost 15 years, and America Realty has taken care of us every year. We never have to worry about anything! We've stayed in many different homes, and now our stays are extended, so we return to the same place each year. Everyone is like family, and we will always count on our American Realty family!�
Judy Hayworth Stevens
Judy Hayworth Stevens
2017-09-22T20:00:17+0000
Beyond our expectations year after year � love your service and your can do attitude!
Mj Siewert
Mj Siewert
2017-09-21T17:00:28+0000
Last year was our first time using American Realty. They were responsive to questions, gave us great information, and were so helpful when we needed to get into our house a little early. The house we rented was super clean and directions that were left were easy to follow. We liked the house so much and the experience was so good that we'll be back again this year!
Peter Stasky
Peter Stasky
2017-09-17T23:16:04+0000
We have dealt with American Realty for as long as I can remember. Could it be 15 years or more. They are the very best. If there is a problem. With your rental.....they fix it immediate and with a great attitudeI wish all were like them
Joan Berkow Schader
Joan Berkow Schader
2017-09-15T21:03:11+0000
Elaine and her staff are the best. We have rented on Captiva for many years. Hands down better than the other agency on the island!
Kristin Santoro
Kristin Santoro
2017-09-12T15:12:55+0000
Bridget Carter
Bridget Carter
2017-09-12T14:05:42+0000
The best staff. Friendliest people. Always willing to do whatever it takes to make your stay the best!!
Eddie Bruce
Eddie Bruce
2017-09-11T12:44:27+0000
Lisa and the entire staff have been terrific for the many years that we have booked a house rental through them. Extra helpful with arranging 2-3 week slots as well as solving the various issues that arise. Alan has been particularly helpful.The Barbers
Marygrace Barber
Marygrace Barber
2017-09-09T18:01:05+0000
Dee Bentley
Dee Bentley
2017-08-23T15:44:08+0000
Great place to stay and relax , fishing is great with great surroundings.
Maria Ortiz
Maria Ortiz
2017-08-23T10:36:34+0000
Captiva has been our home away from home for 29 years. We have been using American Realty all those years and would never consider anyone else.
Michelle Jarboe Copeland
Michelle Jarboe Copeland
2017-08-21T15:15:21+0000
Our experience with American Reality of Captiva has always been phenomenal. We have been staying on Captiva Island every year for 15 years , and always get excellent service at American Reality. Lisa is the best. We have used other companies in the past - nowhere near the personal touch.
Michael Mualem
Michael Mualem
2017-08-20T17:39:23+0000
Excellent staff at ARC ! They helped me find the perfect vacation home . I can't wait to make another reservation!
Janie Roberts Owens
Janie Roberts Owens
2017-08-12T17:02:56+0000
We rent from American Realty every year in Captiva, they are so easy to work with, always pleasant and very responsive to emails. I highly recommend them, you won't be disappointed!
Bev Long
Bev Long
2017-08-09T12:31:00+0000
Friendly and helpful team that has helped provide some of the best family vacations we have experienced.
Kevin O'Brien
Kevin O'Brien
2017-07-26T02:04:48+0000
I have been renting through AMC for quite a few years and have always been very happy with their excellent service. Last year they even found a close to the beach house for us at the last minute!!! They are also immediately responsive to any concerns!!
Kathy Kearns Gilligan
Kathy Kearns Gilligan
2017-07-24T16:51:29+0000
What great people at American Realty! Everyone is super easy to work with and with such a large selection of properties to choose from they were able to fine the perfect place for our family reunion/vacation this June. They were very responsive to any needs and questions and even took care of a special shipment one of our family members needed. We have used American Realty for many years and have always been pleased. They are honest and truly care about their customers. We wouldn't consider using anyone else.
Judith Eberle
Judith Eberle
2017-07-23T22:13:32+0000
We have used American Reality for over a dozen years. They are very helpful, kind and make our stay stress free. I love that I can stop in for a quick hello in the village and get fast feedback if I need something. They are very well thought of, as they have a large percentage of vacation rental listings on Captiva. We look forward to using them for years to come❤️
Kathryn Eslick Freehafer
Kathryn Eslick Freehafer
2017-07-22T15:51:48+0000
We have rented from this company for 4 years on Captiva Island in every year we had a wonderful experience. Super easy in and out, good communication, and whenever we had an issue they were right there to help us take care of it. I even had items shipped right to their office that I needed in a pinch during our vacation. Thank you so much for so many great vacation memories! We will be back again!
Kate Hayman
Kate Hayman
2017-07-18T16:00:53+0000
We have rented on Captiva for a few years now and have been completely satisfiedwith American Realty of Captiva. The staff is always helpful and the properties are well kept. We look forward to renting from them in the future.
Joni Bjorkstrand
Joni Bjorkstrand
2017-07-10T16:33:24+0000
What an easy place to do business with. The home was spectacular and we will definitely be back!
James Hamilton
James Hamilton
2017-07-08T13:45:17+0000
We have been using AMRC for over 18 years and have never had a problem. We rent on Captiva at least once a year - sometimes two or three times. We love the laid-back atmosphere of the island.
Judy Irwin
Judy Irwin
2017-07-06T20:01:54+0000
Surfcomber house on Captiva Island Florida is an ideal vacation home for up to eight people. Right on the Gulf of Mexico, it features 4 bedrooms, 4 1/2 bathrooms and a big pool with two eagles in a nearby tree. �
James McKee
James McKee
2017-07-06T16:26:30+0000
American Realty has worked with us year after year to ensure our accommodations are as good as possible and our stay is great!
James Carol Markland
James Carol Markland
2017-07-06T14:48:13+0000
We had a great experience renting a house on Captiva through American Realty. The house was exactly as described and we had easy access to the property at the time agreed. We will definitely rent throu AR again!
Janet Bartholomew Gearns
Janet Bartholomew Gearns
2017-07-05T01:48:33+0000
We've used AMRC a couple of times now to rent on Captiva. Traveling from the UK, we wanted confidence that the houses would be to a good standard and that we had the back up of a local knowledgeable agent.AMRC delighted us on both counts. Nothing was too much trouble and they happily tolerated international phone calls from a guy with a funny accent!We offer our thanks for past visits and look forward to booking with them again.
Ian Bruce
Ian Bruce
2017-07-04T17:06:13+0000
We have been renting from AMRC for several years now, I really appreciate their properties and how well they communicate with us about availability and details about the homes we rent. Captiva is a beautiful place to vacation, you just can't beat it!
Gwen Sandlin
Gwen Sandlin
2017-06-28T13:21:47+0000
This group at American Realty is the best. They are so friendly and helpful with anything from the reservation process to any problem ( very rarely if at all) that may arise. They are first class in every respect.
Greg Green
Greg Green
2017-06-27T16:07:57+0000
Heidi Strauss
Heidi Strauss
2017-06-26T14:27:55+0000
We used American Realty for the first time this past May. We are familiar with the Captiva area so we chose a place in Sunset Captiva.The rental process was easy, stress free, and convenient to just go directly to the rental without having to go somewhere else to check in first. Our rental was clean and stocked with no issues. We'll definitely use AMRC for future trips!
Tom Hembree
Tom Hembree
2017-06-24T14:50:09+0000
American Realty is the best! We have booked with them year over year. All I have to do is tell them what we are looking for and they always have great recommendations. The homes are always clean and well maintained and they have serviced us quickly when needed. I highly recommend American Realty in Captiva Island!
Susan Wiedie Gregson
Susan Wiedie Gregson
2017-06-23T16:46:11+0000
Susan Grad
Susan Grad
2017-06-22T20:52:47+0000
Gail Halstead
Gail Halstead
2017-06-19T01:31:21+0000
Mary-Ellen Steeves
Mary-Ellen Steeves
2017-06-18T16:35:18+0000
We have going down to Captiva for over 7yrs now an have not used anything else but American Reality of Captiva. Elaine an Chuck along with their staff are top knotch. We have an will continue to recommend American Reality of Captiva to everyone we know an meet. We love Captiva!!
Ellen Hahn
Ellen Hahn
2017-06-12T17:52:03+0000
18 years visiting our paradise island and our friends at AMRC. Nobody does it better. Hope to see you again soon. Love from London �
Elisa Backer
Elisa Backer
2017-06-12T09:11:51+0000
AMRC is a top notch rental company. I have never had a problem with them or any of the properties I have rented.
Eric Allen
Eric Allen
2017-06-11T16:19:52+0000
Carole Levan Favata
Carole Levan Favata
2017-06-07T14:52:08+0000
We have rented AMRC properties on at least two occasions, The Morning Glories, and The Beach Breeze. My Family and I couldn't have been happier with the homes or the service provided by AMRC. We will definitely be coming back soon...
Dan Lynch
Dan Lynch
2017-06-05T21:02:42+0000
My husband and I have dealt with AMRC for over 40 years. Our children were young and now our grandchildren are grown and soon will introduce their babies to CAPTIVA. Lots of changes over the years. Elaine and Chuck (managers) have always been fair to us and do all they can to correct any problems that may occur. It is our Paradis. We hope to have more years with our friends on Captiva. When we can't we know the tradition will continue through our family. Thank you for all the wonderful years.
Sandy Holbert
Sandy Holbert
2017-06-05T01:36:44+0000
These ladies were so helpful and cheerful. They really made the arrangement and stay easy for us. Thanks so much !
Jeanne Hesidenz
Jeanne Hesidenz
2017-05-30T14:37:33+0000
We have been renting from these great people for years. They are so accommodating and easy to deal with, we wouldn't rent from any where else. We have been vacationing in Captiva for over 20 years and have found our favorite spot and our favorite rental company.
Cheryl Horvath Rolwes
Cheryl Horvath Rolwes
2017-05-25T00:44:40+0000
We have been renting with American Realty of Captiva for over 12 years and always have enjoyed our stay and had excellent customer service. What more could you ask for? Hard to imagine renting with anyone else!
Cheryl Cotter
Cheryl Cotter
2017-05-24T14:29:43+0000
So easy to work with, just beautiful homes to choose from.
Christina McNiff Mancinelli
Christina McNiff Mancinelli
2017-05-23T00:21:53+0000
Craig Johnson
Craig Johnson
2017-05-21T18:13:10+0000
We love captive and vacation there every year. You have always been helpful and we appreciate that. See you in November!
Cindy Yanoff Scott
Cindy Yanoff Scott
2017-05-19T16:02:25+0000
These folks are great! We've stayed with them many years and it's always a perfect vacation and great experience.
Barbara Snook
Barbara Snook
2017-05-14T13:05:40+0000
Absolutely love the vacation rental we've stayed in through American Realty! Everyone at American Realty is very friendly and the vacation rental is very nice and accessible to the beach.
Cynthia Trautman Schumann
Cynthia Trautman Schumann
2017-05-07T23:22:24+0000
So great with communication and responding to "issues" re the property!!! We will continue to rent or buy through this realty company!!
Annie Wells
Annie Wells
2017-05-04T14:33:15+0000
Henry Hager
Henry Hager
2017-04-29T14:24:51+0000
We have been renting from American Realty for 4 years and we have been nothing but pleased! Captiva is truly our favorite family vacations spot!
Adam Guthrie
Adam Guthrie
2017-04-26T19:45:39+0000
Alan Schwimmer
Alan Schwimmer
2017-04-26T19:11:00+0000
Sara Karppinen
Sara Karppinen
2016-11-13T07:12:51+0000
Treena Winkler
Treena Winkler
2016-11-10T21:37:47+0000
Abihilash Abihilash
Abihilash Abihilash
2016-11-10T15:52:09+0000